X, a Surgeon, while conducting an abdominal operation on Y, leaves the scissors inside the body of Y. Y suffers lot of pain. Y sues X for damages. Discuss and decide.

You are here:
  • KB Home
  • Model Solved Problems
  • Sem 1
  • X, a Surgeon, while conducting an abdominal operation on Y, leaves the scissors inside the body of Y. Y suffers lot of pain. Y sues X for damages. Discuss and decide.
< Back

Answer:

Y can sue X for damages as X has committed the tort of ‘Negligence’. ‘Negligence’ is the breach of legal duty by omission to do something, which a reasonable man would do or by doing something, which a reasonable man would not do. It is the neglect of care which law requires.

 

  1. Here the defendant namely X, (Surgeon) is under a legal duty of care and skill in conducting the operation.

 

  1. Such a legal duty is towards the plaintiff namely Y.

 

  1. X had failed to perform his duty properly, because he left the scissors inside the body of X.

 

  1. The damage or loss suffered by X is the direct result of the negligence of X. Hence X is guilty of the tort of ‘Gross Negligence’ and liable to pay damages to Y.
Last Updated On January 30, 2018
CartItem Removed. Undo
  • No products in the cart.